The Greatest Film in the Series So Far

Sonic the Hedgehog 3 marks a turning point for the live-action adaptations of Sega’s iconic speedster. Each installment seems to stray further from being just another “family” film, aiming for something closer to the heart-pounding, anime-style narratives that seasoned Sonic fans hold dear. In this third outing, Sonic 3 succeeds in capturing the spirit of one of the franchise’s most cherished stories from its three-decade-long run. Admittedly, some elements have been tweaked, but it embraces the wild, emotional drama that set Sonic apart in the early 2000s. Though it occasionally stumbles with simplistic jokes aimed at a universal audience, the film digs deep into the extravagant, video game essence that makes these characters so enduring.

One of Sonic 3’s standout features is its focus on the nonhuman characters, steering away from the mistake of shoving them aside for less intriguing human plotlines. After the disappointing Knuckles series, which centered too much on its human stories, seeing Sonic 3 allocate meaningful screen time to its anthropomorphic heroes was a relief. Keanu Reeves shines as Shadow, whose storyline, slightly altered from the games, still pulsates with themes of grief and revenge. While his performance in the Shadow Generations DLC was a bit shaky, here, Reeves effectively carries the weight and complexity of Shadow’s storied past.

Drawing heavily from Sonic Adventure 2, Sonic 3 unfolds from dual perspectives akin to its video game counterpart. The film skillfully shifts tones based on which hedgehog—Sonic or Shadow—is in focus. Shadow’s scenes are contemplative and intense, echoing his debut in the Dreamcast game, while Sonic’s parts burst with cheerfulness and optimism. Yet, Shadow’s aura of angst subtly infiltrates Sonic’s narrative, exploring how both characters handle loss.

The stark contrast between Sonic and Shadow in Sonic 3 underscores the film’s strategic shift from its predecessors. Rather than just assembling familiar faces, the film mirrors the narrative structure of Sonic Adventure 2 with purpose. Despite missing Rouge the Bat, who fans hoped to see, the movie emphasizes the distinct yet complementary strengths of Sonic and Shadow. By dropping extraneous tangents like Sonic 2’s wedding subplot, Sonic 3 stays true to the franchise, treating young and old viewers with respect and avoiding patronizing tones. Surprisingly, it delivers one of the most moving explorations of Sonic and Shadow’s dynamics, proving it’s more than capable of handling the darker facets of their characters.

While the central rivalry dazzles, Jim Carrey’s reprise as Doctor Ivo “Eggman” Robotnik left a disappointing taste. In this film, Carrey takes on dual roles: the familiar Eggman and his grandfather, Gerald Robotnik. The latter, traditionally a serious figure, is presented with unexpected humor, which seems out of step with his chilling legacy in the Sonic universe. Although the opportunity to let Carrey improvise between the two roles often misses the mark, leading to scenes bogged down by unfunny gags and misplaced dance numbers.

One of the larger challenges of the Sonic movies has been managing the human characters. Talented actors have been marred by weak scripts that made mundane sequences unbearable. Even with Sonic 3, Jessica Jones alum Krysten Ritter’s role as Director Rockwell is brief and underwhelming. Knuckles barely featured in his own series, and while Carrey previously stole scenes in earlier films, here, these misplaced comedic efforts diminish even his dynamic performances.

The human moments that work best are those tied closely to the leads, like Shadow’s tender bond with Alyla Browne’s Maria or Sonic’s endearing relationship with James Marsden’s Tom. Lee Majdoub returns as Agent Stone, capturing the essence of his character’s troubled loyalty to Eggman. Yet much of the time dedicated to comedic antics sadly chips away at Carrey’s onscreen magic.

Gerald’s surprising presence and characterization highlight some key deviations any Sonic enthusiast will spot. Despite these changes, Sonic 3 remains true to the early 2000s angst, delivering an experience that resonates with both the characters and the audience. Witnessing Sonic and Shadow’s electric confrontations packs serious excitement, and the film’s climactic showdown feels deeply rewarding after what has been a climb through two progressively successful cinematic outings and a lackluster TV series.

Reflecting on Sonic 3, I keep returning to the word “earned.” The series has journeyed far from its initial missteps, like the infamous Ugly Sonic reveal. Each movie has gradually embraced more of the quirky charm and earnest character arcs that have kept Sonic relevant. Twenty years ago, the thought of seeing a beloved game like Sonic Adventure 2 brought to life on the big screen, and done well, would’ve seemed impossible. Yet here we are, and Sonic 3 has truly delivered.